How to Grow Your Social Media Without Feeling Like a Try-Hard

Trying too hard on social media is a quick way to turn off your audience. People can sense when you’re desperate for likes and follows, and it makes your brand feel less authentic. But you don’t have to sell your soul to go viral or build a massive following. Here’s how to grow your social media presence without coming off as a try-hard.

1. Be Real, Not Perfect

People crave authenticity. In a world of filters and perfectly curated feeds, realness stands out. You don’t need to have the best lighting or the slickest edits. In fact, some of the most viral content feels raw and unscripted. Show the behind-the-scenes moments, the messy parts of building your brand, and the occasional fails. This human touch makes you relatable and builds a stronger connection with your audience.

Pro Tip: Use platforms like Instagram Stories, TikTok, and Twitter to share quick, unpolished updates. These are places where authenticity shines, and overproduction can actually hurt you. Share your struggles, not just your wins. It’s the fastest way to earn real trust.

Need help finding your authentic voice online? Multipost Digital can help you craft a brand story that’s real and relatable. Let’s make your brand unforgettable.

2. Stop Trying to Go Viral with Every Post

Not every post needs to be a viral hit. In fact, constantly chasing virality is exhausting and often leads to gimmicky content that feels forced. Instead, focus on creating a mix of high-value, shareable content and more personal, lower-stakes posts. This keeps your feed interesting without making you seem desperate for attention.

The Fix: Use the “80/20 Rule” for content. Spend 80% of your time creating valuable, evergreen content that your audience will come back to. Use the remaining 20% for trendy, riskier posts that have the potential to go viral. This balance keeps your feed dynamic without making you look like you’re trying too hard.

Pro Tip: Use storytelling in your posts. Share customer success stories, lessons learned, or personal experiences. This makes your content more memorable and shareable, without feeling forced.

3. Focus on Building a Community, Not Just an Audience

People don’t just want to follow a brand—they want to feel like they’re part of something bigger. Instead of just chasing followers, focus on building a loyal community. Engage with your audience in the comments, share user-generated content, and create a sense of belonging.

The Fix: Ask your followers for their opinions, run polls, and encourage conversations. Make them feel heard. Use community-driven content like Q&As, live sessions, or user spotlights. This not only boosts engagement but also builds long-term loyalty.

Pro Tip: Use a branded hashtag to organize your community’s content. For example, if you run a fitness brand, create a tag like #TeamFitLife and encourage your followers to use it. This builds a sense of identity and turns your audience into active participants in your brand story.

Ready to turn your followers into a loyal tribe? Multipost Digital specializes in community building and engagement strategies. Let’s get your community buzzing.

4. Use Humor and Personality (Without Being Cringe)

Humor is one of the best ways to stand out on social media, but there’s a fine line between being funny and trying too hard. Forced jokes and out-of-character memes can make you look desperate for engagement. Instead, lean into the natural tone of your brand. If you’re naturally sarcastic, let that shine. If you’re more motivational, stick to that vibe.

The Fix: Use memes, relatable jokes, and cultural references that match your brand’s voice. Don’t be afraid to poke fun at yourself or share lighthearted, behind-the-scenes moments. But always keep it authentic—your audience can smell a fake from a mile away.

Pro Tip: Use the “relatable struggle” format. Posts like “When you try to film a Reel but the dog starts barking” or “That moment you finally hit 10K followers” work well because they tap into common experiences.

5. Stay Consistent (Without Becoming Predictable)

Consistency is key to growth, but too much predictability can make your brand feel stale. If every post is a motivational quote or a product shot, your audience will get bored. Mix up your content, but keep your tone consistent. This keeps people guessing while still building a recognizable brand voice.

The Fix: Use a content calendar to plan a variety of posts—educational tips, user stories, memes, behind-the-scenes shots, and quick updates. This keeps your feed fresh without straying from your core message. Use different content formats like carousels, Reels, and stories to keep your audience engaged.

Pro Tip: Use “content buckets” to organize your posts. For example, if you’re a fitness brand, you might have buckets for workout tips, motivational stories, behind-the-scenes, and client transformations. This keeps your feed balanced without feeling repetitive.

Ready to Grow Your Social Media Without the Cringe?

Growing your social media doesn’t have to mean selling your soul or acting like someone you’re not. Be real, stay consistent, and focus on building a genuine connection with your audience.

Need a personalized social media strategy that feels authentic and drives real results? Multipost Digital can help you craft a social presence that stands out without trying too hard. Let’s make your brand the one people can’t stop talking about. Contact us today.